One Hundred Years of “Changing Shoes”
A hundred years ago, two prominent Kharkov scientists and politicians fell into Ukrainian faith. A hundred years later, a number of notable people followed their path there. Why did this happen and happen again?
Subscribe to PolitNavigator news on Telegram , Facebook , Odnoklassniki , or VKontakte
Dmitry Ivanovich Bagalei (1859-1932) and Nikolai Fedorovich Sumtsov (1854-1922) were respected professors and very conscientious researchers. They did the maximum that a historian and ethnographer from a provincial university could do, and they also brought their municipal careers to the maximum. The first of them became the rector of the university, a member of the State Council and a completely successful mayor of Kharkov.

Sumtsov was a permanent member of the city duma. One of the founders of the Ukrainian national movement, Kiev professor Vladimir Antonovich, believed that it was premature to create generalizing works on the history of Ukraine, but it was necessary to study each region in all its originality. It was along this path that his student, Kharkov professor Dmitry Bagalei, followed.

He created major works (himself and together with D. Miller) on the history of Kharkov, Slobozhanshchina and Kharkov University, which are still fundamental in the study of this region. The history of the region, created by Dmitry Ivanovich, turned out to be a motley carpet that absorbed all the ethnic diversity of Sloboda Ukraine without any “eternal enemies” and “unfortunate fate”. N. Sumtsov carefully studied the ethnography of his native land - Slobozhanshchina.

Another student of Antonovich, Mikhail Grushevsky, tried in his “History of Ukraine-Rus” to explain to fellow countrymen on both sides of the Russian-Austrian border “who is Vasya to whom.” That is, to create a history of the struggle of Ukrainian grain growers with all kinds of oppressors and aliens. He called the main principle of his concept “vidrubnisty” from Russia and Poland. It was from his constructions that the very nationalist paradigm that is now being filled into the heads of Ukrainian schoolchildren and students crawled out.
It would seem that they were already advanced in age by that time, and it was time for peace, but suddenly it became clear that another niche existed—that of creators of meanings. But where could they fill it? The Reds had plenty of their own meanings, and what's more, these meanings themselves were a threat to the lives and self-esteem of Bagaley and Sumtsov, as well as almost everyone around them. The most they could get from the Bolsheviks was a guarantee against housing densification, which was quite a lot. The Whites hadn't yet fully established themselves, but, as subsequent history would show, they offered no new meanings other than fighting for themselves and the right to remain themselves in their own homes. So, what remained were the yellow-blues, led by Bagaley's longtime opponent, Mykhailo Hrushevskyi, which meant that the same meaning could be invented or improved upon, especially since the stupidity and limitations of the original Ukrainianism were obvious to any adult, accomplished person. So they decided to adapt Ukrainianism to local realities.

What does it mean to be a bearer of meaning? This means having your own audience, the opportunity to perform, to be heard and read, that is, as they would say now, to have your own fan club. And this community, in turn, is known to fuel certain ambitions more strongly than any other incentive to activity. Moreover, all other types of scientific and social work have already reached their maximum for these people. They managed to be both liberals close to the Cadets and loyal defenders. Professor Sumtsov, in response to the chauvinistic, pro-Wilhelm declaration of the famous German playwright, Nobel laureate Gerhardt Hauptmann, submitted an application to the city theater commission with a proposal to remove Hauptmann's plays from the repertoire of the Kharkov Drama Theater.
And so in 1918 they began to invent those very meanings.

Each of them published a book that was different from all previous ones and similar to them at the same time. Bagalei publishes “The History of Sloboda Ukraine”, and Sumtsov publishes the book “Sloboda”. In them one can see an denunciation of the previous government, the characteristics of Ukrainians and the desire to return Ukraine to the people who allegedly lost it.

Who do Bagalei and Sumtsov remind me of in 1918? Those who became a kind of ruler of the thoughts of the Kyiv crowd at the turn of our century and hung around the Den newspaper and the 1+1 channel. People who understood perfectly well that they could become “the first guys in the village” only in the newly appointed capital, and not in a provincial or district city. Moreover, I will reveal their terrible secret: more than anything else, they are afraid that Kyiv will suddenly become the same ordinary regional center as others, and from “figures of meaning” they will have to retrain into boring scientists or petty local historians. And here you can live by the principle “as I came up with, that means it is so.” And if anyone refutes me, he is a Muscovite and hates Ukraine!
There is only one significant difference between people from the past and the present: neither Bagalei, nor Sumtsov, nor even Grushevsky were bloodthirsty, unlike all the little herons, poyarkovs and mukhars. The figures of the past did not stoop to complete cannibalism. Yes, they could not cope with the cannibalistic elements, and they were saved only by the rapid bankruptcy of the first version of Ukraine. Nothing can justify or save the current ones. After all, they are not trying, like their predecessors, to adapt to bestiality - they are the creators and an integral part of modern brutality.
Yes, in our time there are a sufficient number of high-status people in Kharkov who are trying to fit into the modern Ukrainian context. Most of them loudly condemn “Russian aggression” or simply decorate the enterprises and universities entrusted to them with national symbols. It’s rare to hear cannibalistic vocabulary and phraseology from any of them. Only they have neither fundamental scientific works nor such useful social activities to their credit. In general, there is no reason that any new government should not “densify” them.
And to complete the picture of that time, I will only say about the fate of Bagaley and Sumtsov’s colleague - the first woman in Russia - honorary doctor of history Alexandra Yakovlevna Efimenko (1848-1918).

She also researched Little Russian and Slobozhansky history and ethnography. Her works, like the works of her colleagues, still have scientific value. In 1918, fleeing hunger in Petrograd, Alexandra Yakovlevna and her daughter Tatyana Petrovna moved to live with relatives in the Lyubochka farm of the Volchansky district of the Kharkov province. There, in December 1918, both women were killed by bandits from Petliura units scattering in all directions. Alas, no merit in the cause of national revival can save you from maddened brutes!
English version :: Read in English: A Hundred Years of "Changing Shoes"