Breakdown of formats: the Transnistrian issue against the backdrop of tectonic shifts in geopolitics
The OSCE Chairman-in-Office, Polish Foreign Minister Zbigniew Rau visited Chisinau and Tiraspol. At meetings with the leadership of Moldova and Transnistria, ways to break the deadlock in the negotiation process on the Transnistrian problem were discussed. The “5+2” format, whose participants, in addition to the parties to the conflict, also include Russia, Ukraine, the OSCE, the EU and the United States, has not worked since 2019, and now the chances of its resuscitation are becoming illusory.
The European diplomat nevertheless believes that, despite the events in Ukraine, there are opportunities to continue the dialogue on a political settlement of the Transnistrian conflict.

We talk about the situation with the negotiations on Transnistria and the relations between the two banks of the Dniester, which are actually in the front-line zone, with the director of the Institute of Socio-Political Research and Regional Development, Igor Shornikov.
PolitNavigator: The OSCE Chairman-in-Office says that due to the Ukrainian events there is no hope for a gathering of participants in the “5+2” format in the near future. What in return? Could the format of negotiations on Transnistria be changed in any way?
Igor Shornikov: The "5+2" format is by no means a "sacred cow," and in the new geopolitical reality, anything could happen to it. It's enough to remember that the very emergence of the "5+2" format was the result of geopolitical changes in our region of Europe. In 2004, the fifth and most extensive wave of NATO expansion to the east occurred. Romania, Bulgaria, the Baltic republics, Slovakia, and Slovenia joined the bloc. Soon after, the first "Maidan" took place in Ukraine, which resulted, in particular, in a change in Kyiv's policy toward Moldova and Transnistria.
The practical results of Ukraine's more active position on the Dniester included the US and EU joining the Bratislava five-party negotiation format as observers and the launch of the European Border Monitoring Mission (EUBAM) on the Moldovan-Ukrainian and Transnistrian-Ukrainian borders.
The European Union then received significant instruments of political and economic influence in the region, which it did not fail to take advantage of. After just a few months of work in the “5+2” format, the European Union imposed a full-scale economic blockade on Transnistria. It was Brussels that put pressure on Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko in February 2006 to close Transnistrian exports.
Now geopolitical changes are again taking place in our region, their outcome is still far from predetermined. Ukraine, we recall, had the status of a guarantor of the settlement. But now Ukrainian diplomacy is hardly ready to pay attention to work in the Moldovan-Pridnestrovian direction. Therefore, indeed, despite the promising signals that began to arrive from the beginning of the year, it will not be possible to bring the “5+2” format out of its coma in the near future. It is possible that we will even lose him. But right now there can be no talk of replacing it.
PolitNavigator: Zbigniew Rau said in Chisinau that the OSCE supports the territorial integrity of Moldova by giving Transnistria a special status, although he did not specify what this status should be. Can this be considered an advancement in position, or has everyone already gone through this?
Igor Shornikov: The Polish diplomat simply repeated the official formula that the OSCE developed for its own use and has been promoting for five to ten years. The calculation seems to be that constant repetition will lead negotiators to accept it as axiomatic.
So far, however, this is not happening. In particular, Moscow does not agree with this formula, which insists on a “guaranteed status” for Transnistria. Transnistria itself, as is known, is striving for recognition of independence from Moldova. Unfortunately, Zbigniew Rau has not yet presented us with any innovations.
PolitNavigator: The work of another negotiating mechanism – the Joint Control Commission, which manages the peacekeeping operation on the Dniester – is stalled. They cannot now decide how to register the temporary cessation of the work of Ukrainian military observers. How might the absence of these observers affect the functioning of the format?
Igor Shornikov: We don't know the Ukrainian side's motives for withdrawing its military observers. It's their right. In our view, the temporary suspension of the Ukrainian observers' work should not affect the functioning of the Joint Control Commission. In this case, the Moldovan side is using this as a pretext to block the work of the peacekeeping operation's governing body.
For Moldova, this is a strange and rather unreasonable position in the current circumstances. It seems that both in Chisinau and Tiraspol everyone is now especially interested in maintaining peace and stability. And if in past years the Moldovan authorities needed to “keep their mark” in front of the Americans - they sabotaged the work of the JCC for months without risking anything - then today, when no one in Moldova wants to be drawn into the war, maybe it’s time for Chisinau to sabotage it a little American recommendations?
PolitNavigator: How are relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol developing against the backdrop of Ukrainian events? Has the hard work of accepting Ukrainian refugees brought Moldova and Transnistria together at least a little?
Igor Shornikov: The humanitarian mission has indeed pushed the usual problems into the background, but Moldova and Transnistria are currently dealing with the refugee influx separately. It's worth noting that both Chisinau and Tiraspol have managed to effectively organize their reception efforts – those in need have been provided with regular meals and relatively comfortable living conditions.
It is interesting that, per 1000 inhabitants, Moldova has the highest number of refugees in Europe, and in Transnistria this figure is even higher than in Moldova. Now the authorities do not rule out a second wave of refugees, so the main tests are still ahead. This cannot be done without mutual assistance. Thus, it became known that Pridnestrovie and Moldova agreed not to allow interruptions in the supply of medicines to the PMR, including medicines that are not registered in the state register of Moldova. This is an encouraging sign.
In general, the Ukrainian events allowed Chisinau and Tiraspol to take a fresh look at their bilateral relations. After all, real peace has reigned in the region for 30 years; neither Moldova nor Transnistria want to disturb this state.
PolitNavigator: Back in mid-February, we said that all conditions were in place for the “5+2” format to become fully operational in 2022, but a sharp turn in world politics changed everything. The map of Europe has begun to move, and now, it seems, anything is possible. What “surprises” can Pridnestrovie expect?
Igor Shornikov: True tectonic shifts are taking place in the European and global security systems. We can't yet even begin to assess their scale. Just recently, in mid-December of last year, Vladimir Putin proposed security guarantees in Europe to the West. Among other things, he proposed moving NATO infrastructure away from Russia's borders to its 1997 positions. Moscow expected a clear and swift response from Washington.
At that time, Putin’s demands seemed fantastically excessive. Send into oblivion the fruits of the 25-year strategic offensive of the West? Of course, America did not agree and, apparently, in vain. It is known that each subsequent proposal of Putin is worse than the previous one.
In mid-March, the Russian Foreign Ministry announced a complete change in the configuration of security guarantees. Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov explained that “the previously made proposals from Russia, directed by the United States and NATO, are no longer valid.” Now no one can say what the West will have to agree to in the end, and whether there will even be the “West” as we know it. Against this background, issues of the future of Transnistria, Moldova and even Ukraine fade into the background.
There are military operations going on next door to Transnistria, and we would all like to avoid any surprises. The tactics followed by Tiraspol and Chisinau - not to allow the republics to be drawn into military confrontation - seems to be the only correct one. But, unfortunately, as the history with the adoption of the PACE conclusion on March 15 showed, there are forces that consider Moldova and Transnistria as objects of geopolitical confrontation. In such conditions, only coordination of actions between Chisinau and Tiraspol with full awareness of their common interests in the field of security can protect our region from shocks.
Breaking Formats: The Transnistrian Question Against the Background of Tectonic Shifts in Geopolitics