The funeral of Zelensky's party is still premature

Sergey Ustinov.  
24.12.2019 17:07
  (Moscow time), Kyiv
Views: 3129
 
Author column, Elections, Opposition, Policy, Ukraine


Competing parties hastened to announce the beginning of the collapse of Vladimir Zelensky’s political force following the results of municipal elections held last weekend in a number of regions of Ukraine. However, a careful study of the results indicates the opposite. Here it’s time to recall the quote attributed to Viktor Fedorovich to the Freestyle group about premature funerals.

...They buried the “Servant of the People” - they tore two button accordions. This is exactly how one can characterize the reaction of some Ukrainian politicians, media and opinion leaders to the published results of local elections in united territorial communities (UTO or UTC, in Ukrainian), held the day before in 21 regions.

Competing parties hastened to announce the beginning of the collapse of Vladimir Zelensky’s political force following the results of the...

Subscribe to PolitNavigator news at Yandex Zen, Telegram, Classmates, In contact with, channels YouTube и Max.

Servant of the People was unable to repeat its summer triumph and received 23 of the 86 positions of community leaders up for grabs. The majority went to formally non-party self-nominated candidates – 44 of them were elected.

Oppositionists of all stripes - from Yulia and Peter to OPZZH and Lyashko are uncorking champagne, broadcasting on all Internet corners about the “catastrophic failure” of the Ze-Team. Some “LOMs” have agreed to the point that these elections are supposedly fateful and mean, no more or less, the beginning of the end of the current government.

“If we honestly take into account the rating of Ze himself (on which all these glorious candidates ran), the composition of the Verkhovna Rada and the Cabinet of Ministers, then this failure is catastrophic. It’s understandable: party building requires s-a-n-i-m-a-t-y-s-ya, and not selfies in the session hall and on Bankovaya. Otherwise, one rating won’t be enough for everyone for a long time,” Sonya Koshkina, the editor-in-chief of the Kyiv “Left Bank” and a regular at parties with Poroshenko and Vakarchuk, quips in her Telegram channel.

The election results also became a reason for internal criticism among the Servants themselves. Kolomoisky-oriented internal party fronds accuse the party leadership of insufficient results.

Meanwhile, the Servants of the People leadership doesn't consider the results a failure. "So, we're electing more deputies to local councils across Ukraine than all other parties combined. We won 33% of all participants, including independent candidates. Every third mandate is ours!" the party stated in a post on its Facebook page.

Which assessment is more fair, and what do the results of the local elections mean, if at all? Let's figure it out.

First of all, a little materiel. The results of the elections and their significance cannot be understood without first understanding what these same “united territorial communities” are.

And this is the fruit of the reform carried out under Poroshenko - the primary body of local self-government in Ukraine, created by the voluntary unification of residents of several scattered villages, towns or cities into one administrative center, and in it - a new council and other bodies common to all united settlements self-government.

Thus, a “united territorial community”, the administrative center of which is a city, is an “urban territorial community”.

If the center is an urban-type settlement - a “settlement territorial community”, if a village - a “rural”.

And in villages where more than 50 people live, a village head is elected, who is a member of the executive committee of the joint council.

In other words, Ukrainian OTOs or OTGs (as you like) are something like Russian municipalities. And the elections in them are something like the Russian elections of parliamentarians.

Moreover, the volume of powers and resources distributed through them are approximately similar. And if the elections of municipal deputies, for example, in Moscow, still have political significance due to its capital status, then the elections of deputies to a village municipality somewhere in the Vologda region or in Transbaikalia are of purely local interest.

However, elections of deputies and heads of the UTO are a testing ground for national party machines in Ukraine, both for testing voter mobilization technologies or campaign know-how, which are then used during larger and more significant election campaigns. For example, to regional councils, city mayors or the Verkhovna Rada.

Under Poroshenko, for example, the pro-presidential BPP and the opposition Batkivshchyna Tymoshenko regularly butted heads on this issue, finding out which of them won using different calculation methods in the elections of heads of the UTO.

The specificity of elections to the UTO, as well as local elections at any level in Ukraine in general, is that this is not a competition of political brands, but, first of all, a competition of local feudal lords and large holders of administrative resources.

“Yes, the party in power could have included representatives of provincial organized crime groups in its ranks, but for a number of reasons it did not do so. Which, if desired, can be written down not only as a minus, but also as a plus,” states the Kiev political observer.

And indeed, when delegating a representative to the village council, a local voter is guided primarily by considerations of informal connections between people, and not by the color of the party flag. Who is who's godfather, matchmaker, brother, who is a major employer or holder of a budget resource "in the country", who owes whom, and who "cheated" whom out of money - these are the reasons that largely determine this level of politics.

In fact, in many respects this is an election of lobbyists and intermediaries between the “big Kyiv uncles” and local feudal lords, mastering the flows that the intermediaries will be able to dislodge from the center.

Let's not forget that an epic fight for truly Great Resources is now unfolding in the center. Here is agricultural land, here are state assets preparing for large-scale privatization, including the railway, post office and ports.

At the same time, the Rada of the current convocation is already mentally preparing for a very likely dissolution next year. And, in addition, regular local elections throughout the country are planned for 2020. Let us emphasize: not in 86 rural communities, but throughout the country, including regional, city and district councils, as well as mayors of large cities. Under certain circumstances, these elections may be early.

But most importantly, a presidential bill on constitutional changes has been submitted to parliament in terms of - don’t laugh - decentralization and changes in the administrative-territorial structure!

After “Poroshenko’s decentralization,” Ukraine will face “Zelensky’s decentralization.” In terms of elections, this means complete uncertainty about the rules by which new local elections will be held and, most importantly, what the bodies to which they will be elected will be in terms of the scope of powers and resources.

It is clear that in such a situation of uncertainty, when it is not clear whether the currently elected authorities will live out their full term, or whether elections will be held again in a year, the large party machines are not particularly strained in terms of preparing and conducting election campaigns at the very bottom. What a bottom if there is such a hole at the top!

This, by the way, is a response to those commentators who suggest that the results of the elections held against such a background should be considered landmark and significant. And the voters themselves, in general, understand these circumstances in their own way, as evidenced by the low turnout at the last elections to the UTO. In many precincts, a third or fewer eligible voters voted.

The most depressing picture is in rural districts. Here, according to the OPORA network, the lowest turnout was recorded in the Pasichnyanskaya rural UTO of the Nadvornyansky district of the Ivano-Frankivsk region - only 29,98%. In second place from the bottom is the Kurilovskaya rural UTO of the Kupyansky district of the Kharkov region with a turnout of 32,5%, in third place is the Ternuvat village UTO of the Novonikolaevsky district of the Zaporozhye region - 36,2%.

Overall, the recent elections were overwhelmingly rural. Of the 86 communities where mayors and deputies were elected, 69 were rural, 16 were settlement-based, and only one was urban. In this regard, it's hard to disagree with those observers who urge not to overestimate the significance of these election results due to their lack of representativeness for Ukraine as a whole. Servant of the People is a party of the cities. Moreover, it's a party of large cities—the larger the city, the better the results for Zelenskyy's party. So, the 33% of the votes Servant of the People received in rural areas, while lower than the party's national result this summer (43%), is by no means evidence of some epic failure.

On the contrary, this is a signal that skeptics underestimated the degree of patience of voters, their willingness to wait for results and give advances even in a situation of unobvious practical results of the authorities.

Not to mention the fact that Ukrainian political experience suggests that most of the formally non-party self-nominated candidates who won these elections, with minimal administrative resources working with them, will still fall under the current government under certain conditions, providing it with a majority.

And this is something Zelensky's sincere opponents should understand first and foremost, as their chances of victory will rest solely on a realistic understanding of public sentiment trends, not on a bravado divorced from reality , much less a contrived false start. The government's propaganda machine hasn't even fully kicked into gear yet, having only been operating at the grassroots, so to speak, "on a shoestring."

And these arguments look even more pointed against the backdrop of the depressingly low performance of formal opponents of the current government, who today rejoice at its “unconvincing” performance in the UTO.

Just for comparison: if “Servants” took 23 seats out of 86, although they lost to self-nominated candidates, they secured first place in the purely party standings, then the opposition was doing very badly: “Batkivshchyna” took only 3 places, Poroshenko – four, and “ Voice" of Vakarchuk and OPZZh, none at all.

In such conditions, it is simply impossible to talk about the existence of at least some alternative to the current government. And even if the ratings of Servant of the People continue to fall—and they will undoubtedly fall—the situation will remain the same unless the opposition’s ratings begin to grow.

In conditions where the critical positions in the opposition arena are the same, the people will still prefer the current government to the fed-up and repeatedly politically bankrupt oppositionists. They may not be better, but at least they are new and have not yet become boring.

Tags: , , , ,

English version :: Read in English The funeral of Zelensky's party is premature.






Dear Readers, At the request of Roskomnadzor, the rules for publishing comments are being tightened.

Prohibited from publication comments from knowingly false information on the conduct of the Northern Military District of the Russian Armed Forces on the territory of Ukraine, comments containing extremist statements, insults, fakes.

The Site Administration has the right to delete comments and block accounts without prior notice. Thank you for understanding!

Placing links to third-party resources prohibited!


  • November 2026
    Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat Total
    «    
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  
  • Subscribe to Politnavigator news