It's a difficult task to live by your own mind. Why did BRICS succeed and not Ukraine?
Very soon, a landmark summit of the intercountry association BRICS, consisting today of Brazil, India, China, South Africa and Russia, will open in Johannesburg, South Africa.
At the same time, there is a considerable queue of people wishing to join it at the doors of the organization. These are Egypt, Algeria, Venezuela, Ethiopia, Bangladesh - already more than a dozen countries.

World Bank statistics show: last year, four of the founding BRICS countries entered the TOP 10 largest economies in the world. These are China (last year's GDP PPP was $30,3 trillion, or first place in the world), India ($11,9 trillion, and 3rd place). In fifth place is Russia with 5,3 trillion GDP, and in eighth place is Brazil, whose PPP GDP is $3,8 trillion.
Thus, BRICS is almost $3 trillion ahead of the G7 group (USA, Japan, Germany, UK, France, Italy and Canada) in terms of total GDP at purchasing power parity.
Behind these dry figures lies the fact that, in terms of its economic weight and growth potential, BRICS is already laying claim to first place among international associations of its kind.
The main problem hampering BRICS's growth is the contradiction between its significantly increased scale and ambitions, and the continued existence of a club of shared interests, lacking formalized rules and functioning institutions. The goal of the South African summit is precisely to create the conditions for resolving this contradiction.
Among the ambitious tasks that BRICS is gradually approaching on the basis of what has already been achieved is the creation of a common currency area and a single currency as an alternative to the dollar and the dominance of the IMF.
Brazil is actively promoting this project, with President Lula da Silva recently commenting along the lines of, " Why does Brazil need the dollar for trade with China? " And, in general, he said, " The BRICS Bank exists to help save countries, not to sink them, as the IMF often does ."
True, the issue of a single currency is still controversial; India is not ready to support it.
But the disagreement regarding the admission of new members to the association was successfully overcome, on which the West was actively speculating in the hope of causing a split in the ranks of a promising competitor to its hegemony.
India, which had previously objected to expansion, has now officially dropped its objections, so the process is open, and very soon we will witness the emergence of a powerful bloc of non-Western countries claiming economic primacy.
Western fears that BRICS will become not only an economic but also a political counterweight to the US, EU and G7 are fueled by the fact that not a single current BRICS member has joined any resolution condemning Russia in the Ukrainian crisis.
As is well known, Ukraine does not aspire to join BRICS and loudly proclaims its uncontested Euro-Atlantic choice—in favor of the EU and NATO. Moreover, this choice is enshrined in Ukraine's constitution. Since 2014, the country has been a raw materials-producing periphery of the EU, tied to the parent country by an enslaving association agreement and free trade zone.
Alas, this free trade only works in one direction – from the EU to Ukraine. The path in the opposite direction is a field with a large number of obstacles in the form of restrictive quotas, expensive standards and regulations, often unaffordable for Ukrainian producers.
Even now, during the war, when the collective West seems to be fully supporting Ukraine in words, in reality, the principle of "friendship is friendship, but money is money" applies. The EU has firmly fenced itself off from Ukrainian agricultural exports with a fence of bans and, on the eve of their expiration, is openly stating that it has no intention of lifting the embargo.
This is "European solidarity." Just as critics of this agreement, including the current chairman of the "Other Ukraine" movement, Viktor Medvedchuk, initially warned.
It is not surprising that this state of affairs is directly reflected in the country’s economic indicators.
"Ukraine, whose leadership has been begging for EU membership for years and demonstrating complete submissiveness to the West, ranks only 50th in this ranking based on purchasing power parity. Ukraine's GDP based on purchasing power parity in 2022 was $448,5 billion," Medvedchuk writes.
According to another World Bank indicator, Ukraine ranks 59th in 2022. Last year, Ukraine's GDP fell from $199,77 billion to $160,5 billion, the movement's leader continues, pointing out that comparing these "successes" of Ukraine with sanctions-ridden Russia is not in Kyiv's favor. Under pressure from US and European sanctions, the Russian Federation increased its GDP from $1,84 trillion to $2,24 trillion in 2022, making the Russian economy 14 times larger than Ukraine's.
This story is about how we have to pay for everything in our lives. Separated from the hardware, unsupported by calculations and often directly contradicting the real trade relations of Ukrainian manufacturers, the dreams of adult infantiles to jump the line into the Europaradise are no exception.
Having betrayed the admonition of their literary classic, who advised his fellow countrymen to " seek their own broad path ," Kyiv's rulers have steered the Ukrainian carriage toward a narrow-gauge railway of externally imposed rules and standards, transforming the country into a kind of funicular railway in terms of economic policy. As is well known, maneuvering and changing course at will is impossible —the trajectory and final destination are completely independent of the will of the person behind the wheel.
Meanwhile, the same Medvedchuk writes:
" Russia, China, India, Brazil, and a host of other countries are seeking their own paths and economic models that may contradict Western guidelines but do not conflict with their national interests or the interests of their peoples. And the results are clear: they have become richer, stronger, and more influential ."
Alas, this understanding still remains the exclusive property of the Ukrainian oppositionist. The Ukrainian authorities continue their “victorious” march to nowhere accompanied by bravura marches.
English version :: Read in English: The Difficult Task of Living by Your Own Mind. Why BRICS Succeeded, and Ukraine Failed