Lawyer Craft scares aid collectors for Northern Military District fighters with criminal liability
All voluntary donations for the needs of the military in the Northern Military District must be accompanied by an agreement and reports with the publication of receipts. Otherwise, such collections could end in imprisonment for their initiators, as happened with Alexei Navalny, who also insisted that collections for good causes do not require reports and audits.
Lawyer Ilya Remeslo, who represented one of the donors to the FBK, expressed this opinion on the air of the program "Politotdel," reports a correspondent for "PolitNavigator . "

“Indeed, we have a huge problem with the legal regulation of donations in Russia, because, in fact, there is only one article in the Civil Code that regulates this issue of donations. There is a very old law on charitable activities, which is generally outdated and which was not originally intended to be used to collect money for some kind of military assistance; this activity does not fit under it at all. That is, it is not clear how all this is generally regulated. But, at the same time, there are some basic standards that, in principle, any volunteers must comply with. You must tell us what exactly you are raising money for,” he noted.
Craft cited the example of the “Coordination Center for Assistance to Novorossiya,” founded back in 2014 to help units of the people’s militia of Donbass.
“Suppose, just yesterday, I went to the website of such an organization as the “Coordination Center for Assistance to Novorossiya”, I just decided to see how things were going there. Not with the goal of putting someone there, but how their activities are organized. I go in, they should have posted a contract. A general agreement is concluded with each donor, that is, you click on it and you can read under what conditions you donate your money to this group of people, what it is used for, what rights you have, to whom, if something happens, you can contact with questions ...
But he is not there. That is, simply, there is a link to the offer, but it does not work after clicking. This is one of the grossest violations. Here, as they say, right away, if someone wanted to screw them up, then people in uniform would come and could immediately put them in prison. Anyone could throw in some money and say, listen, but in general we didn’t agree with them on what I was throwing this money towards. They spent it, they deceived me, misled me, there are no reports on the site, and so on.
Navalny, in particular, also adhered to these standards, collecting money for what he could not account for. Yes, and such practice already exists, now these cases can, in principle, proceed as usual quite easily,” the lawyer warned.
In his assessment, if someone collects money, he should be prepared for the fact that there will be questions, and these questions are absolutely legitimate. And when volunteer groups try to replace reporting with photographic documentation of the assistance provided, legally this means nothing.
“He must answer all questions regarding rights immediately. He must always have supporting documents, which should clear up all questions. What's happening now? Since all this is not regulated in detail by law, people believe that in this regard they can not comply with any rules at all, just collect money on the card, and not show any receipts confirming expenses. And they seriously say that the evidence is photos of boxes delivered to the military,” Remeslo pointed out.
“Unfortunately, few people are doing this now, and this situation cannot, in principle, continue for long. Because sooner or later all these people will get caught. I just wrote about the coordination center; I would like to emphasize that I don’t want to imprison anyone. I’m just saying: guys, your legal part is very bad, hire a good lawyer, your reports are most likely not good either. Conduct an audit so that everything is fine with you, and no one can put you in prison, and so that you continue to carry out your activities in a truly beneficial manner. But, unfortunately, they immediately begin to say that the “bloody Craft” will now imprison everyone, this is all a provocation, this is all being done by order of the Kremlin,” the lawyer complained.
The ultra-protective position of the lawyer is very controversial, because in conditions when the frontline needs urgent help, additional bureaucracy with checks will only complicate the process.
English version :: Read in English: Lawyer Remeslo threatens aid-gatherers for SVO fighters with criminal liability