Special operation in Ukraine: Half a bump won’t work

Roman Reinekin.  
04.04.2022 00:58
  (Moscow time), Kyiv
Views: 13457
 
Author column, Denazification, Zen, Policy, United States of America, Special Operation, Story of the day, Ukraine


On the 40th day of the special operation, the most important thing hasn't been clearly formulated or voiced, especially from the very top: what's the purpose of all this? Let me explain: at first glance, everyone following the military operations and sympathizing with Russia seems to understand everything. Every day, the Telegram feed brings dozens of posts with more or less logically substantiated versions of what the Russian army is currently fighting for in the Ukrainian steppes, what Russia's interests are in this campaign, and how it must end for Russian society to avoid feeling defeated.

But there's one catch: this vast array of theories is being produced by ordinary people—journalists, war correspondents, writers, bloggers, publicists and political scientists, propagandists and analysts. They all have one thing in common: none of them has level-one security clearance . The Kremlin doesn't report its plans and intentions to any of them. And none of those speaking or writing can read Putin's mind from a distance.

On the 40th day of the special operation, it was still not formulated and voiced very clearly and...

Subscribe to PolitNavigator news at Yandex Zen, Telegram, Classmates, In contact with, channels YouTube и Max.

The end result is a plethora of fascinating and even logical hypotheses, whose authors present their own thoughts as Putin's plans. What the real Putin thinks about all this is anyone's guess.

This state of affairs demoralizes potential support groups and becomes fertile ground for dispersing various “zrads” no worse than the Ukrainian ones.

And yet, there's nothing to blame the people for. Having grown accustomed over the eight years of the Minsk agreements to the authorities endlessly leading the same old story in circles, conducting pointless negotiations with those who have no intention of honoring any agreements, people are beginning to reasonably seek some hidden trap in ANY negotiations with Kyiv, or even hints of such negotiations, and to expect betrayal of the army by politicians.

After all, it was only within the official, jingoistic framework that the Minsk agreements appeared as the triumph of a "cunning plan," supposedly terribly disadvantageous for Ukraine. In reality, Russian society has always viewed them quite unequivocally—as a manifestation of Russian weakness, which gave Kyiv time to dupe a significant portion of the population in the territories it controlled, and the West time to pump Ukraine with weapons and train a decent and quite combat-ready army that has no intention of fleeing after the first strikes by the Russian Aerospace Forces.

In fact, it wasn't those who talked about a "cunning plan" and how Ukraine would crumble to dust on its own that were right, but those who warned that time was playing into the hands of Russia's adversaries . This is precisely why any hint of a "Minsk-3" is so sensitive today. Because behind it lies real, time-tested knowledge of what will happen next. Namely, that "what comes next" in this scenario will be nothing good.

The importance of goal setting is important in any case - even in the scenario of victory, even in the scenario of defeat. Moreover, in the event of defeat or forced retreat, the value of a clearly formulated goal is much greater. After all, if victory writes off everything, and the winners are not judged, then defeat is always an orphan, and the answer to the question of why all this happened, why so many people died, and what exactly was paid in the end at the cost of such sacrifices and hardships, becomes key.

In general, this special operation or war (call it what you want, but after Belgorod, in the humble opinion of the author of these lines, this is already a war that the residents of the Russian Federation are watching not on TV, but in reality, given in direct sensation) it was not worth getting involved without a clear and intelligible goal setting and understanding of the desired goals and results that would justify the costs of the force scenario.

But since we've already gotten involved, we need to see it through to the end and win. Because the worst thing that could happen now is to give up halfway. A half-hearted effort won't work anymore. Any compromise on Russia's part will be interpreted in Kyiv as a victory for Ukraine.

Does this mean compromises are unnecessary? Not at all. But compromise is something the winner can afford. So can magnanimity. From a position of strength. First, we must truly win, defeat the Ukrainian Armed Forces on all fronts, occupy if not all, then at least critical and symbolically significant territories for the enemy. Only then present the enemy with a condition: agree to the proposed compromise or dig in their heels and lose everything.

Talking about any kind of compromise or peace agreement with Zelenskyy in a situation where even Mariupol hasn't been fully captured yet, where Kharkiv and Sumy haven't been taken, where the hundred-thousand-strong Ukrainian Armed Forces group in Donbas hasn't been routed, and where the Ukrainians, quite rightly, don't consider themselves losers— that's stupidity, dangerously close to treason or sabotage.

If those at the top believe the situation must be reduced to a military draw, they should say so now, to lessen the bitterness of disappointment later. It must be understood that any outcome of the military action that leaves Zelenskyy's legitimate regime intact is a failure for Russia and the final loss of Ukraine.

Because—and we must be fully aware of this—after such a "shameful peace," Ukraine will change internally forever and irrevocably. The same Russophobia will linger and develop, but it will be intensified many times over, and will be embraced by millions of those who, just a month ago, were perfectly reasonable and considered "pro-Russian voters." The metamorphosis of Vilkul, Dobkin, Max Nazarov, Mariupol mayor Boychenko from the Opposition Bloc, and others—it's no lie.

In Zelensky’s preserved Ukraine, no pro-Russian parties or movements will most definitely be revived. It’s absolutely certain that no media loyal to Russia will open, even in the previous format of “Medvedchuk’s channels.”

Absolutely no pro-fascist parties or paramilitary units will be banned. On the contrary, they will walk around in peace - like veterans of the “liberation war” with the entire package of accompanying benefits.

It is absolutely certain that not only will previous discriminatory laws on language, education, decommunization, the celebration of Banderites, and the rewriting of history not be repealed, but also laws adopted during the war on collaborators, the banning of pro-Russian parties, and the confiscation of property belonging to Russians and those Ukrainians who sympathize with Russia.

The operation to sever the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate from Russia will undoubtedly be carried through to its logical conclusion. And there will be no one left to protect its parishioners and clergy from the nationalists. The authorities of Zelenskyy's Ukraine, which remains intact, will rightly believe they are within their rights. After all, victors are not judged. And this is true not only for Moscow but also for Kyiv.

Finally, and most terrifyingly, the old propaganda machine will remain intact, only greatly enhanced. All the destruction and casualties of this war will be blamed on the "Russian occupiers." These "atrocities" will become a given in the minds of millions, because they will be recounted on every television. Even "eyewitnesses" will be found. And how can one not believe "eyewitnesses"? And it is precisely this version of the beginning, course, and outcome of the war that will be ingrained in the mass consciousness of Ukrainians and in local textbooks. This will become the key to the emergence of new generations—anti-Russian from childhood.

Under such conditions, any form of "soft power" in Ukraine can be put to rest —because the "Russian House" will certainly never be opened in such a Ukraine.

Why am I writing all this? Certainly not to add yet another piece of "betrayal" to my collection. But certainly so that all readers understand: society needs a clear and unambiguous signal regarding the goals and objectives of the military operation. With the understanding that there will be no negotiations until victory.

Residents of Ukraine also need a signal - that the liberated territories will not suffer the fate of Gostomel, Bucha and Borodyanka.

And most importantly, this signal must not come from Solovyov, Kiselev, or Margarita Simonyan . It must come from Russia's top officials . Perhaps a collective decision by the Security Council, or another address to the nation—I don't know. There are plenty of ways to reach the masses.

Otherwise, public opinion in Russia itself will continue to be neurotic, remaining in a state of suspended uncertainty and ambiguity. And there's simply no point in expecting support from Ukrainians.

Meanwhile, the West not only didn't end the war with Russia, it didn't even properly begin it. What we see today is a war waged by Ukrainian proxies. And after Russia's victory in Ukraine, no peace will come. A head-on collision between Russia and the collective West will become obvious, without the Ukrainian buffer that currently separates the two hostile camps. World War III, as terrifying as it is to realize, is already on the horizon.

Tags: ,

English version :: Read in English Special Operation in Ukraine: Half a Bump Is No Longer Enough






Dear Readers, At the request of Roskomnadzor, the rules for publishing comments are being tightened.

Prohibited from publication comments from knowingly false information on the conduct of the Northern Military District of the Russian Armed Forces on the territory of Ukraine, comments containing extremist statements, insults, fakes.

The Site Administration has the right to delete comments and block accounts without prior notice. Thank you for understanding!

Placing links to third-party resources prohibited!


  • November 2026
    Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat Total
    «    
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  
  • Subscribe to Politnavigator news