Galicia is not Piedmont!
In 1906, in Austro-Hungarian Lemberg (also Lvov, populated by Poles and Jews), an article by professor-historian Mikhail Grushevsky “Ukrainian Piedmont” was published. In it, a native of Little Russia argued that the unification of Ukraine would come from Galicia as the most developed and free territory for the settlement of a divided people.
Subscribe to PolitNavigator – Kyiv news on Facebook , Odnoklassniki , or VKontakte
To make this province's superiority more apparent, he compared it to Italy's Piedmont, which led the unification of the country 45 years before this article was written. Calling Hrushevsky a failure or a layman is impossible: it is well known where and with whom he studied, what books he read, and his mastery of the generally accepted methodology of the time. Therefore, it can be said that this is a case of deliberate forgery.
Piedmont, legendary and real
Since 1720, the Sardinian Kingdom existed on the world map, becoming the legal successor of the Duchy of Savoy with the ruling dynasty of the same name. Like most Italian lands (except Sicily) it was subject to Napoleonic invasion and was restored by the Congress of Vienna 200 years ago. The dynasty ruling there differed from all others who sat on Italian thrones only in that it was of local and not foreign origin, and in maintaining constitutional government.
The various branches of the Habsburgs and Bourbons and the theocratic Papal States clearly did not fit into the ideology of the “spring of nations”, which was then fashionable in Europe. Early nationalism had its origins in romanticism, which called for the search for roots, the collection of folklore or the falsification of epics and the creation of national states in the place of outdated, as it seemed to the “progressive public”, cosmopolitan empires and patchwork territories.
Piedmont had something that the Ruthenian population of Galicia never had - its own aristocracy and urban population. In the process of unification under the auspices of the Savoy dynasty, foreign troops were expelled, archaic monarchies and the secular power of the papacy were eliminated. King Victor Emmanuel II used the French army and the revolutionaries of Giuseppe Garibaldi as allies. “We created Italy, now we need to create an Italian,” said the last head of the government of Piedmont and the first prime minister of Italy, Camillo Cavour.

Galicia under Poland completely lost not only its aristocracy, but even its intelligentsia. The photo shows the cover of the magazine “Rusalka Dniestrovaya”, one of the first Russian-Ukrainian magazines with folk art, published in Lviv for almost two centuries under the undivided rule of Poland over the region.
Having eliminated the medieval institutions that interfered with the unification, the Piedmontese did not touch the local elites, did not try to humiliate the population of the annexed regions and populate the conquered cities. Moreover, the king’s new subjects began to participate in government activities on an equal basis with the old ones. The high selective property qualification involved the aristocracy and bourgeoisie of all liquidated states in the construction of a united Italy. And how it turned out further, you can see in the famous film by Luchino Visconti “The Leopard”.
There was a simple extension of the legislation of the Sardinian kingdom to all of Italy. The problems of uneven development of the north and south of the country, erasing cultural differences and relieving humanitarian discomfort have been solved in an evolutionary way for more than a century and a half, and since 1946 - without the participation of the Savoy dynasty. Attempts by Mussolini's fascist regime to forcibly eliminate traditional self-organization of the population, such as the Sicilian mafia, failed. The country is united bureaucratically and infrastructurally, the Italians are created and no longer dream of restoring, say, the Tuscan Habsburgs or the Parma Bourbons.

Poster for the film "Leopard" (originally "Cheetah")
Not Piedmont!
In Galicia, at the time of the appearance of Grushevsky’s article, the aristocracy was mainly Polish, and the bourgeoisie and philistinism were Polish and Jewish. The educated Rusino-Ukrainian population was small, and the Austrian authorities decided to use it as a counterweight to Polish dominance. And if we compare the two situations (Galician Piedmontese), then the Lombardo-Venetian region was part of the Danube Empire, and the movement for the unification of Italy was associated with the expulsion of the Austrians. Solitaire doesn't work anymore!
Why was Ukrainianism encouraged in Austria-Hungary? Firstly, in order to have someone to oppose the local Poles, whom the court of Franz Joseph did not consider loyal subjects. Although the Jewish revival (haskalah) had been going on in the empire for almost a century, the authorities also did not see support in the Jews. Therefore, it had to be sought in the local rural population through the formation of its most active part.
Secondly, to neutralize the influence of " Muscovophiles " and, of course, Russia, with which relations by that time were no longer as friendly as they had been before the Crimean War. The Russophobia of local Ukrainians was not only welcomed but encouraged . With the outbreak of World War I, Ukrainianizers became complicit in the massacre of "Muscovophiles" and happily sent their neighbors to the Thalerhof and Terezin camps.
A graduate of the St. Petersburg Military Law Academy, Trofim Zenkovsky, at the anniversary of Taras Shevchenko in 1890, was the first to point out that Austrian Galicia and Russian Ukraine had switched roles and now Galicia was becoming the main cultural center of Ukraine. He was supported by M.S. Grushevsky. In 1906, he wrote: “In the last decade of the XNUMXth century, Galicia, despite its own difficult conditions of national and economic existence, became the center of economic movement and, in relation to the Ukrainian lands of Russia, played the role of a cultural arsenal, where the means of national cultural and political-social revival of the Ukrainian people." However, in the next article, “Galicia and Ukraine,” the researcher describes the social movement in Western Ukrainian lands somewhat differently. In this article, he notes that it is “the Galician social habit to see and imagine Galicia as the spiritual and cultural center of the Ukrainian land, as that spiritual factory where Ukrainian culture is cultivated for the whole catholic Ukraine.”
This position was still quite moderate and at first did not go beyond scientific debate and educational activities. But from it also grew an aggressive movement, subsequently represented by the “Sich Riflemen.” It was in their midst that the idea of creating an ethnically pure Ukraine by exterminating the non-Ukrainian population arose. The commander of this unit, E. Konovalets, became the founder of the OUN.

K. Cavour is one of the founders of modern Italy. His ideas did not contain the misanthropic phobias of neighboring peoples. He collected parts of the country, and the Galicians have been fighting against another part of it with varying success for a century
The Italian idea did not know anything like this, neither in the progressive-romantic (G. Mazzini), nor in the pragmatic (Victor Emmanuel II, C. Cavour) or even in the fascist (B. Mussolini) version. No matter how cruelly different political forces could deal with each other, the idea of genocide came to the country only in 1943, after the overthrow of Mussolini by the king and Marshal Badoglio and the entry of German troops into the north of the country. On the territory of Ukraine and in the diaspora it has become natural and, sometimes hidden, has become quite pronounceable even by officials since 2014.
For example, Luhansk region military-civilian governor Tuka stated: "I would like to bring them back (the territories under LPR control), but without the 'wadhati,' without the separatists," Tuka said. "For terrorists, there should be only one option—prison. And those who didn't take up arms but supported the bandits should be provided with one-way tickets—to Rostov and Taganrog. How this is accomplished is another matter: maybe revoke their citizenship, maybe do something else. One thing is clear: they have no place in our country ."
I note that since the president, prime minister, speaker or other official in Kyiv did not refute these words, then they can be considered the official position of Ukraine in relation to some of its citizens.
But in Galicia such a view seems quite normal. And where is the kinship with Piedmont, which found the answer for all Italians?
English version :: Read in English Galicia is not Piedmont!