Prisoner exchange: Zelensky wins the battle in the information war

Peter Ugryumov.  
10.09.2019 15:23
  (Moscow time), Kharkov
Views: 2460
 
Author column, Society, Odessa, Political repression, Права человека, United States of America, Russian Spring, Ukraine


The Ukrainian side clearly gained more propaganda and information benefits from the exchange of prisoners and prisoners. This is happening because the Russian media openly gave the initiative to the Ukrainian “partners”.

The thesis that Ukraine is exchanging Ukrainian citizens for Ukrainian citizens was heard at all exchanges: in 2014, in 2017. Now it is actively “used” by pro-Russian housewife bloggers. But how far can one go in the information war (the same one that Zelensky announced not so long ago, and no one abandoned these plans) with such sluggish attempts to prove one’s moral superiority?

From the exchange of prisoners and prisoners, the Ukrainian side clearly gained more propaganda and information benefits...

Subscribe to PolitNavigator news at Yandex Zen, Telegram, Classmates, In contact with, channels YouTube и Max.

It seems that attempts to critically reflect on the outcome of the exchange occur mainly on social networks. People, let’s say, uncivil, who understand who they exchanged for whom and at what cost, remain gloomily silent or limit themselves to interjections.

Well, so what if the lawyer of the rebel Ruslan Gadzhiev sounded the alarm and loudly appealed to the interested party: one person from the exchange list was not brought to the collection point! And it was already clear based on the results of the 2017 exchange: the Ukrainian side does not disdain cheating methods. Of course, now the players have changed somewhat. But who said that they will be honest in everything? Yes, Russia brilliantly won the game that Poroshenko started last November in foreign territorial waters, receiving plus 24 points for the upcoming exchange. But today’s Ukrainian player still resembles Paramon Korzukhin (Evstigneev) in the film “Running,” when he, having already lost to General Charnote, tries to steal at least one bill for himself. Just as stupidly and brazenly, the Ukrainian side left the Russian citizen Gadzhiev in prison.

But we did not expect any special manifestations of nobility and strict adherence to moral standards from the Ukrainian “exchangers”. But why did Russian propaganda so calmly swallow all this, pretending not to notice? Why in Vesti Nedeli didn’t Kiselyov make a fuss about the cheating (it’s minor, but the fate of one of the 35 prisoners is at stake, and this is not a small thing) on ​​the Ukrainian side? After all, this is not only possible, but also had to be done: to start the story about the exchange not with the one we meet at the airport, but with the one we missed. After all, this should be the norm. Or how?!

The story of Vesti Nedeli about the exchange was entirely devoted to Kirill Vyshinsky alone. Kiselev and Skabeeva met him at the plane's steps... One can understand this joy for his freed colleague, which outweighed everything. But one cannot understand this sudden loss of professionalism. Other participants in the exchange only occasionally appear in the frame. And then, these shots - for example, with the Russian Alexei Sedikov, who was captured in the Donbass - were taken by Vyshinsky himself on the plane. And the story of this militiaman, who almost lost his leg in captivity, does not bother any of the pillars of Russian propaganda?

And we already went through all this after the last exchange. Take, for example, the tragic story of Alexander Kushnarev, the father of Gennady Kushnarev, who died in the Odessa House of Trade Unions. “Bastard” Alexei Goncharenko posed above Gennady’s body in front of the lens. Alexander Kushnarev, a university teacher, was accused of preparing an assassination attempt on Goncharenko. He was exchanged in December 2017, and has since lived and worked in Donetsk. Yes, during this time it was possible to film a modern variation of “The Fate of Man” about him, a feature series. And we even saw the “bastard” Goncharenko on the air of Russian political talk shows almost more often than Alexander Kushnarev. Although people like Kushnarev still deserve a different format - not a screaming political talk show, but something more serious. Something that Russian propaganda hardly works on.

And we can talk about this propaganda lethargy, predictability, and stiltedness in the kitchen (on social networks). In the hope that this will not be the end of the matter. There is time before the next stage of the exchange to correct the mistakes and mistakes made now. And then, perhaps, Mykola Yanovich Azarov in his Facebook posts will not confuse the age of the oldest political prisoner in Ukraine. Candidate of Technical Sciences Mehdi Logunov is 85 years old, and the exchanges of December 2017 and September 2019 passed him by. And Mehdi Logunov was 84 years old at the time when Mykola Yanovich Azarov needed to start (or continue) to be interested in the fate of the oldest political prisoner... And then Perhaps Mehdi Logunov would have received more qualified legal support even before his sentencing (12 years on charges of treason) or would have been included in the exchange list of 35.

There is still time for Vesti Nedeli to remind Ukraine and Zelensky every Sunday that the new president inherited the most shameful legacy from Poroshenko: an 85-year-old inventor sitting in a pre-trial detention center for dissent! As long as Mehdi Feofanovich is alive, it is not too late for the president to sign a pardon - regardless of the date of the next exchange. And it is not too late to start Russian discussions of the exchange topic with a reminder that the 85-year-old political prisoner should have been first on the list for exchange. And it could be Skabeeva and Kiselev who met him at the plane’s steps...

And those responsible for the information front have time to get to know what people who have not forgotten how to reflect think about all this. We need to work on mistakes now, otherwise their repetition is inevitable.

Human rights activist Vladimir Rybin (father of lawyer Valentin Rybin, representative of the Odyssey Foundation, which provides support to political prisoners, including many Russians in Ukrainian prisons) writes about this on social networks: “The experience of exchanges of detainees has shown that one of the main The problem is the technical problem of collecting information, preparing a list of candidates for exchange and its verification. Russian Ombudsman Tatyana Moskalkova is not able to cope with this work alone, since it requires a huge amount of time traveling to specific institutions and contacts with detainees, their lawyers and prosecutors. The upcoming exchange of “all installed for all installed” involves, at a minimum, their “installation”. Everyone without exception. Otherwise, you will have to blindly trust the official representatives of the Ukrainian side, who constantly either include “dead souls” in the list, or arbitrarily exclude those still alive from it.

In addition, not all of the installed ones are ready to exchange. Citizens of Ukraine reasonably believe that they do not have the right to be expelled from their homeland. They are the subjects of the upcoming amnesty, but they also need to be identified so that no one is accidentally forgotten.

Moscow probably needs to establish cooperation with the Ukrainian side and give the necessary powers to its authorized representative working in Ukraine, who is capable and willing to carry out this difficult and, frankly speaking, unsafe work for him. Will Moscow find such a person? Hard to say. But if not, a repetition of past mistakes is inevitable. And they simply need to be avoided.”

Tags: , , , , ,

English version :: Read in English Prisoner Exchange: Zelensky Wins the Information War






Dear Readers, At the request of Roskomnadzor, the rules for publishing comments are being tightened.

Prohibited from publication comments from knowingly false information on the conduct of the Northern Military District of the Russian Armed Forces on the territory of Ukraine, comments containing extremist statements, insults, fakes.

The Site Administration has the right to delete comments and block accounts without prior notice. Thank you for understanding!

Placing links to third-party resources prohibited!


  • November 2026
    Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat Total
    «    
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  
  • Subscribe to Politnavigator news