Are the changes in Crimea really that radical? – Author's column

Moscow - Sevastopol, April 07 (Navigator, Viktor Yadukha) - The reunification of Russia with Crimea has already become a turning point for relations between Russia and the West. Perhaps it will also become a turning point in the development of Russia itself. But what will this change on the peninsula itself?

Columnist Viktor Yadukha , an employee of the Russian agency Rosbalt, discusses this in his column for Navigator .
Subscribe to Navigator Kyiv news on Facebook or VKontakte
...This question seems stupid and even blasphemous: how is this “what?” Yes all! But if you list the changes known today and project them onto the fabric of everyday life for Crimeans, they will not seem so total.
Yes, the Russians will invest in infrastructure. Yes, they will strengthen the fleet. A bridge will be built across the Kerch Strait. Yes, the incomes of Crimeans and Sevastopol residents as a whole will increase, although not for everyone. Pensioners, civil servants and security officials will definitely experience an increase. For Black Sea Fleet servicemen, on the contrary, the salary will be reduced (without additional payments for “abroad”, a lieutenant will receive almost 30 thousand rubles less). Changes in the private sector will be ambiguous: winemakers will have a more difficult time, small and medium-sized businesses in general will have to adjust for a long time to supplies from Russia and to the more complex and competitive Russian market. The first couple of years will be more difficult for resort owners. The operation of ports will change. Retail prices and tariffs will increase, although hardly as much as in Ukraine since May.
Serious changes await the humanitarian sphere: the teaching of history, the school curriculum in languages and literature, and the book market will change radically. Office work, advertising, electronic media and dubbing of Western films will completely switch to Russian.
But these changes are so expected that the consciousness of the majority of the population of the peninsula has long been ready for them and will take them for granted. That is, there will most likely be no “wow effect”. Most will have a warm feeling of returning home - perhaps not to the USSR, but to a country more similar to it than Ukraine. For example, now the Crimean police are actively being transferred to Russian legislative framework, and those who still remember the Soviet Ministry of Internal Affairs see greater similarity between Russian police rules and Soviet ones.
Is it good or bad? Of course, it’s good if most people like change. However, with all this, it is important to understand: the class and estate system of relations in society is unlikely to change significantly.
Russia is richer than Ukraine, but it has the same, if not greater, stratification between rich and poor; the same, if not greater deindustrialization, dependence on the import of finished products and ready-made intellectual solutions from abroad; the same large-scale problems with the values that unite society and the same complex of secondary importance in relation to Western ideas and ideologies.
The rich and noble in the Russian Federation, despite sanctions from outside and so far futile attempts to “nationalize the elites” from within, for the most part continue to keep their money and families in the West, teach their children there, fly there on weekends, working in Russia on a rotational basis - like drillers in the Far North. Yes, they are, in general, “drillers”.
Despite the encouraging statements of high officials about moving away from the dollar in international payments and about creating its own payment system, the Russian economy remains totally, slavishly dependent on Western banks and offshore companies. And, if Western sanctions do not become tougher, Russia may well remain like this - just now with Crimea.
All this means that the ruling class in the Russian Federation still does not believe in the bright future of the country and does not want to participate in its construction, still remaining for the most part treacherous and comprador.
In other words, Russia’s economic and spiritual sovereignty has yet to be built. In the meantime, as someone aptly put it, Russia and Ukraine are “standing in line at the same checkout counter of a global supermarket.” This means that, at its core, “Crimea” has not yet changed either the lives of its inhabitants or the life of Russia itself. And in this sense, it is too early to call the changes “total” or “radical”.
They may object to me: okay, but what about the annexation of Crimea to Russia in 1783? The changes weren't radical then either? After all, life in Russia under Catherine was even less fair than it is today.
I will answer: then the annexation of Crimea certainly entailed total changes - if only due to the difference in the ways of life of the Tatar Khanate and the Russian Empire. Now there is no such difference.
By the way, there is one interesting point here. Supporters of Ukraine, of which there are actually quite a few in Crimea and even in Sevastopol, call the departure of Crimea a “total change” not only because they feel a deep trauma that will sting for years. But also because we are sincerely convinced that the entire paradigm of Crimea’s development has changed. In their opinion, Ukraine is already a more “European” habitat than the Russian Federation, and its prospects for becoming Europe in all other respects are closer. That is, until February 26, Crimea was “going to Europe,” they believe, and now it is “falling into the totalitarian Asian Mordor.”
All this, of course, is very controversial. If we ignore the milder climate and the constant fight between lords, which only makes the slaves' forelocks crack, and which on this basis is passed off as democracy, then most of Ukraine is hardly a more European place. Here we generally enter a minefield of speculation. Do you have a “European” Lviv? And we have Kaliningrad and St. Petersburg! Are there no Asian migrant workers in Kyiv and almost no violent Caucasian youth on the streets? Yes, but this is more than compensated for by the terrible neglect of the city, boorish parking on the sidewalks, ruins in courtyards even in the center, the dilapidation of the entire infrastructure, and the garish poverty of residential areas. It is customary for pro-Western media to write about this, but take a ride and check for yourself: such a devastated mess has not been seen in Moscow for a long time. Yes, everything is regulated, the fines are high. But you haven’t been to Finland yet. To Europe - so to Europe, do not confuse tourism with emigration.
Morals in Ukraine, seemingly softer and more humane, for some reason give a similar social picture: wild lordship and meager slavery reign in both countries, which in fact remain parts of the same socio-cultural space. The same corruption at the top, the same banditry at the bottom: for every Russian “totalitarian” Kushchevka in Ukraine there is its own “democratic” Vradievka.
And it remains to be seen which country will move faster along the path of socio-economic and technological progress: bankrupt Ukraine, backed to the wall by an IMF ultimatum, or Russia, which, through “I don’t want,” is being forced to shake off a bad dream by Western sanctions. I personally think that Russia will show progress faster. Not because I am for her, but because she has the resources and experience of sovereign statehood. Ukraine has neither one nor the other. IMF loans have not yet pulled anyone out of the Third World, and the difference between EU membership and Association with the EU is the difference between a metropolis and a colony.
Of course, there is also “pure” geopolitics. Crimea has always been important for Russia as an unsinkable aircraft carrier, and post-Maidan Ukraine would quickly raise the question of withdrawing the Black Sea Fleet. Russia in general - alas and ah - cannot historically survive except as an empire: it is being pushed towards this by the Great Russian Plain itself, where it is impossible to guard the borders unless they are expanded to natural barriers - mountain ranges and seas. Which is exactly what happened at all times. In this regard, yes, history is being made before our eyes. “The wind of Russian history has returned.”
But if we return to the changes in the way of life in Crimea, they are unreasonably exaggerated. The nature of things will not change. And whoever was will remain whoever.
In my opinion, the most important thing on the peninsula now is not what happened, but what did NOT happen. There was no war. There was no ethnic massacre. The Black Sea Fleet will not be replaced by the NATO fleet. And, of course, the historical, civilizational connection between Crimea and Russia will not be broken, which would most likely happen after the Maidan - no matter how Moscow behaves. Sometimes a good event is the absence of a bad one.
English version :: Read in English Are the changes in Crimea really that radical? – Author's column